Want hotel discounts? or and enjoy special deals while they last!

Menu

Hotels in Fishers Island (NY)

Choose the best offer for you!

100 results

FiltersClear all
  • Booking cancellation
  • Star Rating
  • Guests rating
    • Travellers Rating
  • Property type
  • Search nearby
    • more
  • Hotel facilities
  • Hotel name

Check hotels near Fishers Island (NY)

  • Born Free Motel
  • 115 South Emerson Avenue, Montauk (NY) NY 11954
  • 25.9 km from center of Fishers Island (NY)
  • 3.5 / 5

    TripAdvisor Travellers Rating:

    72 reviews

    Very good
  • Hotel Red Roof Inn Mystic New London
  • 707 Colman Street, New London (CT) 06320
  • 14.6 km from center of Fishers Island (NY)
  • 3.5 / 5

    TripAdvisor Travellers Rating:

    440 reviews

    Very good
  • Rodeway Inn Waterford - New London
  • 211 Parkway North, Waterford (CT) 06385
  • 17.4 km from center of Fishers Island (NY)
  • 4 / 5

    TripAdvisor Travellers Rating:

    155 reviews

    Very good
  • The Taber Inne & Suites
  • 66 Williams Avenue, Mystic (CT) 06355
  • 11.6 km from center of Fishers Island (NY)
  • 4.5 / 5

    TripAdvisor Travellers Rating:

    332 reviews

    Excellent
Inn/Lodge
  • Old Lyme Inn
  • Inn/Lodge85 Lyme Street, Old Lyme (CT) 06371
  • 26.4 km from center of Fishers Island (NY)
  • 4 / 5

    TripAdvisor Travellers Rating:

    164 reviews

    Very good
Bed&Breakfast
  • Inn at Harbor Hill Marina
  • Bed&Breakfast60 Grand Street, Niantic (CT) CT 06357
  • 15.6 km from center of Fishers Island (NY)
  • 5 / 5

    TripAdvisor Travellers Rating:

    639 reviews

    Excellent
Bed&Breakfast
  • Whitehall Mansion
  • Bed&Breakfast42 Whitehall Avenue, Mystic (CT) CT 06355
  • 14.6 km from center of Fishers Island (NY)
  • 3.5 / 5

    TripAdvisor Travellers Rating:

    59 reviews

    Very good
  • Bellissimo Grande Hotel
  • 411A & 411B Norwich Westerly Road , North Stonington (CT) 06359
  • 23.8 km from center of Fishers Island (NY)
  • 4 / 5

    TripAdvisor Travellers Rating:

    923 reviews

    Very good
Bed&Breakfast
  • Abbey's Lantern Hill Inn
  • Bed&Breakfast780 Lantern Hill Road, Mashantucket (CT) CT 06339
  • 23.6 km from center of Fishers Island (NY)
  • Hilltop Inn & Suites
  • 373 Norwich Westerly Rd, North Stonington (CT) 06359
  • 23.6 km from center of Fishers Island (NY)
  • 3.5 / 5

    TripAdvisor Travellers Rating:

    247 reviews

    Very good
Bed&Breakfast
  • Sunrise Guest House
  • Bed&Breakfast681 Old Montauk Highway, Montauk (NY) NY 11954
  • 26.1 km from center of Fishers Island (NY)
  • 4.5 / 5

    TripAdvisor Travellers Rating:

    174 reviews

    Excellent
Resort
  • The Ocean Resort Inn
  • Resort95 South Emerson Avenue, Montauk (NY) NY 11954
  • 25.9 km from center of Fishers Island (NY)
  • 4.5 / 5

    TripAdvisor Travellers Rating:

    929 reviews

    Excellent
  • Hartman's Briney Breezes Beach Resort
  • 693 Old Montauk Highway, Montauk (NY) NY 11954
  • 26.1 km from center of Fishers Island (NY)
  • 4.5 / 5

    TripAdvisor Travellers Rating:

    685 reviews

    Excellent
  • A Wave Inn - Montauk
  • 32 Elmwood Avenue, Montauk (NY) NY 11954
  • 25.8 km from center of Fishers Island (NY)
  • 3 / 5

    TripAdvisor Travellers Rating:

    104 reviews

    Good
  • Ramada by Wyndham Groton
  • 156 Kings Hwy, Groton (CT) 06340
  • 12.7 km from center of Fishers Island (NY)
  • 3 / 5

    TripAdvisor Travellers Rating:

    782 reviews

    Good
Bed&Breakfast
  • Bee and Thistle Inn and Lounge
  • Bed&Breakfast100 Lyme Street, Old Lyme (CT) CT 06371
  • 26.5 km from center of Fishers Island (NY)
  • 4 / 5

    TripAdvisor Travellers Rating:

    155 reviews

    Very good
  • Super 8 by Wyndham Groton
  • 173, Route 12 , Groton (CT) 06340
  • 12.8 km from center of Fishers Island (NY)
  • 2.5 / 5

    TripAdvisor Travellers Rating:

    731 reviews

    Good
Summer House
  • The Captain's Quarters
  • Summer House126 South Emerson Ave, Montauk (NY) NY 11954
  • 25.9 km from center of Fishers Island (NY)

Offer for you - hotel cheaper to 30%!

It is true. Once you have purchased your air ticket you will have access to a special accommodation offer at much better prices!

  • This special offer is for accommodation in the country you are visiting.

  • You will get access to the offers with special discount.

  • Special offer is connected with purchased flight ticket.

Get an extra hotel discount for registered users. It's free!

Log in and check our extra discount! These prices aren't available for everyone.

  • Find offers marked as "Member pricing".

  • Choose the perfect one and enjoy your trip!

  • Don't have an account? Sign up in a few seconds.